In 2006, Google
launched a major endeavor to put the contents of books into its search engine.
In other words, a person can now access Google and do a search that will pull
up the content of different books.
The Google Book Scanning Project
includes the contents of books in its search program in two ways:
First, the Google Book Scanning Project makes available the entire contents
of significant (famous, highly regarded or important) books through a Google
search. For example, because the Bible itself is within the public domain, and
because it is an important book, Google takes the position that it not only
can, but should, make the entire contents of the Bible available to people
through its search engine. (Books in the public domain are books written so
long ago that there no longer exists any exclusive copyright claim to them. The
works of William Shakespeare are another example.)
Second, the Google
Book Scanning Project is stepping beyond public domain books by including many
books protected by copyright laws. Google is scanning in the entire contents of
these books. Google maintains that it only allows a person the ability to
access a portion of the text through the Google Book Scanning Project. Google
maintains that it follows the Fair Use Doctrine by providing only a limited
amount of the text of a book protected by copyright law.
The Google
Book Scanning Project has been met with mixed reviews. In some sectors, the
Google Book Scanning Project has enflamed the debate over how the Fair Use
Doctrine is intended to work.
The Fair Use Doctrine permits the
limited usage of copyrighted material for academic purposes. A researcher can
utilized a small portion of copyrighted text as part of an academic paper or
research report. Similarly, a student can utilize copyrighted material as part
of his or her own academic efforts. As mentioned before, Google contends that
its efforts fall within the Fair Use Doctrine.
Writers and other
people with a keen interest in copyright enforcement contend that Google has
gone beyond the Fair Use Doctrine in its Google Book Scanning Project. In fact,
when copyrighted books were introduced into the Google system in 2006, people
accessing these books via the Google search engine were able to view the text
of any book included within the Google Book Scanning Project. These people
argue that Google has gone too far beyond the limited use (with attribution)
that is contemplated by the Fair Use Doctrine.















